Jataka · Day 149 · Week 22
The Forty-Year Silence
A hermit under a banyan in old Kasi has not spoken for forty years. A proud scholar arrives with forty-nine questions, and the hermit offers only cool water and a kind look.
Moral of the story: Quiet kindness can teach more than many words.
In this story
- Characters
- The Silent One, The young scholar
- Source text
- Jataka tales
- Value
- Kindness
- Read time
- 4 min read aloud
Day 149 at a glance
- Week
- Week 22 · day 2 of 7
- Trimester
- Trimester 2
- Baby this week
- Baby's sense of touch grows. Eyebrows and eyelids are well formed. Week 22 baby development
- Today's story
- The Forty-Year Silence
- Garbh samvad
- “Are you touching your face? It's a beautiful face.” Talk to your baby this week
Tradition holds, in the Jataka stories, that a calm and steady presence can teach more than many words. Research on maternal calm suggests that quiet, unhurried moments may help a mother's breathing and heartbeat settle.
"He always gave them water first, before a single word."
Rice in a leaf bowl, cool water in a clay pot: every morning the villagers carried these into the forest at the edge of the old kingdom of Kasi. They were taking them to a hermit who lived under a great banyan tree. The Jataka tales say that in this life the Bodhisatta, the one who would one day become the Buddha, was that hermit.
The villagers called him only the Silent One. Once he had been a teacher, with a lively school of young students. Questions had flown through the afternoon air like sparrows. Then one morning, without telling anyone why, he walked out into the trees, sat down under the banyan, and did not speak again.
Forty years passed. The kings of Kasi changed three times. The banyan grew wider, letting down new roots like slow brown ropes. The hermit grew older and thinner and gentler, the way a river stone grows smooth over a long, long time.
Children brought him wild flowers. He touched each one to his forehead and smiled. Sometimes a mother came with a crying baby on her hip and sat in the banyan's shade, rocking. Soon the baby stopped crying and simply looked up at the leaves. Nobody could say why. People went home feeling less afraid of their own lives.
One day a young scholar arrived from the capital. He had read every book in the library and won every debate at court. He carried a list of forty-nine questions, neatly numbered, on a fresh strip of palm leaf.
The path had been long and the day was hot. His feet were sore and dusty. Before he could say a word, the old hermit rose slowly, poured water from his own clay pot into a cup and held it out.
The scholar blinked. He mumbled his thanks and drank. The water was cold and tasted faintly of earth.
He sat down across from the old man, cleared his throat and read out the first question.
The hermit looked at him. He did not speak.
The scholar waited. A leaf fell. A koel called somewhere far off. The hermit kept looking at him with eyes that were not unkind, only very steady.
The scholar read the second question. No answer. He read the third. By the seventh his voice had grown small. By the twelfth he had stopped reading altogether.
He sat with the palm leaf in his lap. Silence seeped into him the way water seeps into dry earth: slowly, completely, without a sound. He heard the wind moving in the banyan. He heard his own breath. And he noticed, for the first time in years, how fast his heart had been racing all along.
When the sun slanted low through the branches, the scholar stood up. He did not make a speech. He only touched the empty cup to his forehead, the way the old man touched the flowers. Then he walked back towards the village.
Halfway down the path he stopped at a stream. He took out his palm leaf of questions and let it slip into the water. He watched it float away like a little green boat.
For the rest of his life, people said of him, "He listens well." When tired travellers came to his door, he always gave them water first, before a single word. He had learned that under a banyan tree, from a cup offered in silence.
Years later, when the scholar was old himself, a young student asked him what the Silent One had taught. He thought for a long while. Then he went to the kitchen, filled a cup with cool water, and set it in the student's hands.
Back in the forest, the banyan kept letting down its slow roots, and the clay pot sat in its shade, full and cool, ready for the next tired traveller.
Little one, before any words, your mother is already giving you her quiet.
More from Jataka tales
3 min read · pregnancy & ages 3–8 · also known as “Chalis saal ke maun ki kahani”
Source: Jataka tales · Traditional retelling
Behind this story
The Jataka collection of the Pali canon gathers around five hundred and fifty stories of the Buddha's earlier lives, and many of them feature hermits whose teaching is patience and restraint. This one, set in a forest near Kasi, is told in that tradition. It is distinctive because the lesson contains no words at all. A proud young scholar arrives with forty-nine questions on a palm leaf, and the old hermit answers only with a cup of cool water and a kind, steady gaze. By the twelfth question the scholar has stopped reading, and later he floats his palm leaf down a stream like a little green boat. For an expectant mother, its final line is tender: before any words, she is already sharing her quiet.
- Theme
- kindness, calm, wisdom
- For pregnancy week
- This story is for week 22 of pregnancy
- Updated
Characters
- The Silent One
- — A kind hermit, the Bodhisatta, who teaches through silence.
- The young scholar
- — Proud at first, he learns to listen.
The moral
Quiet kindness can teach more than many words.
What to say to your baby
My little one, even in silence I am sending you all my love.
Ask them when they're older
What did the hermit give the scholar instead of answers?
Source: Buddhist Jataka tradition (Pali canon)