Sufi · Story library
Mulla Nasruddin Says "You Are Right Too"
Two neighbours quarrel over an apricot tree leaning across their wall. Nasruddin tells each of them, "You are right," and then tells his puzzled wife she is right too.
Moral of the story: Listening to every side makes room for peace.
In this story
- Characters
- Mulla Nasruddin, The two neighbours, Nasruddin's wife
- Source text
- Nasreddin Hodja folk anecdote ('You are right too')
- Value
- Wisdom
- Read time
- 4 min read aloud
- Also spelled
- Mulla Nasruddin / Nasruddin / Nasreddin / Mulla / Hodja / Nasreddin Hodja
3 min read · pregnancy & ages 4–8 · also known as “Mulla Nasruddin tum bhi sahi ho”
Source: Story in the Sufi tradition
Behind this story
'You are right too' is one of the most quoted Nasreddin Hodja anecdotes, shared from Turkey and Iran to Central Asia and India, usually with a judge hearing two plaintiffs and agreeing with both. This retelling places the quarrel over a leaning apricot tree between two neighbours, with Nasruddin's wife putting down her peas to object, which makes it feel like a scene from a real courtyard. Unlike versions that stop at the joke, the shared laughter leads the neighbours to share the apricots and the sweeping. For a growing family, it is a light-hearted reminder that a home can make room for everyone's side.
Behind Nasruddin's famous joke is real wisdom: most quarrels hold some truth on every side, and patient listening plus a shared laugh can soften hearts better than a stern verdict.
"You are right too," he said.
In a village where grapevines climbed over every wall, the people chose Mulla Nasruddin to settle their quarrels. They said he had a good heart and a clear head, and that he never sent anyone home without a smile.
So on certain afternoons he sat on a cushion in the shady courtyard of his house. A jug of cool water stood beside him, and his wife sat nearby, shelling peas into a wooden bowl. Bees hummed in the jasmine, and the old fig tree threw cool, lacy shadows across the stones.
One warm afternoon two neighbours came stomping through the gate. Their faces were hot, their beards bristled, and they were both talking at once.
"One at a time, my friends," said Nasruddin, lifting a gentle hand. "Sit. Drink some water. Then tell me."
The first neighbour sat down with a thump. "Mulla," he began, "there is a wall between our gardens. My apricot tree grows on my side, but its branches lean over the wall."
"This man picks the apricots that hang over his side. He says they fall on his land, so they are his. But the tree is mine! I planted it, I water it, I care for it. Surely the fruit is mine too."
Nasruddin listened with his eyes half closed. He nodded slowly. He stroked his beard.
"You are right," he said.
The first neighbour beamed. He folded his arms and looked very pleased with himself.
Then the second neighbour leaned forward. "Mulla, please, hear me too," he said. "Those branches shade my vegetables so they cannot grow. The leaves drop into my well. The fallen apricots draw wasps into my garden, where my children play."
"I sweep up his leaves every autumn. I chase away his wasps every summer. If his tree hangs over my land and troubles me all year, surely a few apricots are a fair thank you."
Nasruddin listened again with his eyes half closed. He nodded slowly. He stroked his beard.
"You are right," he said.
Now the second neighbour beamed. The first neighbour's mouth fell open. The two men stared at the Mulla, then at each other.
At this, Nasruddin's wife set down her bowl of peas. She had been listening the whole time, and she could not keep quiet a moment longer.
"Husband!" she said. "What kind of judging is this? You told the first man he is right. Then you told the second man he is right. They cannot both be right!"
Nasruddin turned to her with the same calm face. He nodded slowly, as kindly as before. He stroked his beard.
"You are right too," he said.
For a moment the courtyard was perfectly still. A sparrow hopped along the wall. Somewhere a goat bleated, and far off in the lane a water seller called out his song.
Then the first neighbour snorted, and the second neighbour chuckled, and soon all three of them were laughing so hard they had to wipe their eyes.
"Well," said the first neighbour, still laughing, "if we are both right, perhaps we should share the apricots."
"And perhaps," said the second, "you could help me sweep the leaves in autumn."
They shook hands. Their faces were no longer hot, only kind. They walked out of the gate together, already talking about apricot jam, and whose wife made the sweetest, and how many jars a good summer might bring.
Nasruddin's wife shook her head, but she was smiling as she picked up her peas again.
The Mulla sipped his cool water. He knew a secret: when two people each hold a piece of the truth, the best way forward is often to hear them both, and to laugh together.
Sleep softly, little one. In our home there is room for everyone's side, and plenty of laughter too.
More from Mulla Nasruddin
- Source
- Story in the Sufi tradition
- Theme
- wisdom, compassion, calm
- Updated
Characters
- Mulla Nasruddin
- — A peacemaker who listens to everyone.
- The two neighbours
- — Quarrelling friends who learn to share.
- Nasruddin's wife
- — She asks the funny question everyone is thinking.
The moral
Listening to every side makes room for peace.
What to say to your baby
Sleep softly, little one. In our home there is room for everyone's side.
Ask them when they're older
How did the neighbours stop quarrelling?
Source: Nasreddin Hodja folk anecdote ('You are right too')