Sufi · Story library
The Elephant in the Dark
Travellers keep an elephant in a dark barn in a town where no one has seen one. People feel it by hand, and each is sure it is a pipe, a fan, a pillar or a throne.
Moral of the story: We each see only part of the truth, so we should listen to one another.
In this story
- Characters
- The townspeople, The elephant
- Source text
- Jalaluddin Rumi, Masnavi, Book III, 'The Elephant in the Dark House'
- Value
- Wisdom
- Read time
- 4 min read aloud
3 min read · pregnancy & ages 4–8 · also known as “Andhere mein haathi Rumi ki kahani”
Source: Story in the Sufi tradition
Behind this story
'The Elephant in the Dark House' comes from the third book of Jalaluddin Rumi's thirteenth-century Persian Masnavi, and it echoes the much older Indian parable of the blind men and the elephant found in the Buddhist Udana and in Jain teaching. Rumi's version has its own quiet touch: the people are not blind, only without a candle in a dark barn, so each confidently calls the elephant a water pipe, a fan, a pillar or a throne. The fault lies in the darkness, not in them, and a single light would have joined their words. This telling closes on Rumi's gentle invitation to patience and listening. In pregnancy, it is a calm reminder to meet differing views with kindness.
Each of us touches only a part of any big truth. Rumi's story invites patience and humility, so that differing views become pieces of one picture rather than reasons to quarrel.
The elephant, after all, had never been in pieces. Only their seeing had been.
Long ago, in a quiet town far from any jungle, the people had heard many tales of a creature called the elephant, but not one of them had ever seen it.
One evening, travellers from Hindustan arrived with a great surprise. They had brought an elephant, and they led it, slow and swaying, into a dark barn at the edge of the town.
News ran through the lanes faster than a breeze. "An elephant! An elephant has come!"
Everyone wanted to see it at once. But it was night, and the barn had no lamps, and no one thought to bring a candle.
The children tugged at their mothers' sleeves. The old men put on their best caps. Even the baker left his warm ovens and came running, flour still on his hands.
At the barn door they could hear it: a deep, slow breath, like wind in a cave, and the soft shuffle of very large feet on straw. Everyone felt a little shiver of wonder.
So the people went in one by one, into the deep, warm darkness, with their hands held out in front of them.
The first man stepped forward and his palm touched something long and round that curled and moved. "Oh!" he said. "The elephant is like a water pipe!"
The second man's hand found something wide and thin, flapping gently against his fingers. "No, no," he said. "The elephant is like a great fan."
A third man reached low and touched something thick and firm, standing still on the ground. "You are both mistaken," he said. "The elephant is like a pillar, a strong pillar of a temple."
A fourth woman stretched up and laid her hand on a broad, smooth back. "It is like a throne," she said, "wide enough to sit upon."
Another touched the smooth, curving tusk and called it a ploughshare. Another found the little tail and laughed, "It is only a rope!"
They came out of the barn one after the other, each holding a different picture in the mind.
Soon the square was full of voices. "A pipe!" "A fan!" "A pillar!" "A throne!" Each person was so sure, because each had truly touched something real.
They began to argue, and their voices grew louder and louder, while inside the barn the elephant simply stood in the dark, breathing slowly, calm and whole.
The great poet Rumi, who told this story, said that each of them was a little right, and each of them was a little wrong.
"If each of you had held a candle," he said, "your words would have agreed. You would have seen the whole elephant, and there would be nothing to quarrel about."
He said that our eyes are like the palm of a hand. A palm can touch only one small part. It cannot hold the whole of a great thing at once.
The sea is one, Rumi said, but we see only the foam on the waves. We point at the bubbles and say, "This is the sea," and forget the deep water beneath.
So the poet asked us to be gentle with each other's words. When someone says "pipe" and someone says "fan," perhaps they are both describing the same wonderful creature.
And he asked us to look for the candle: the quiet light of patience and listening that lets us see more than our own small part.
If the people of that town had walked into the barn again with a lamp, they would have gasped together. A trunk like a pipe, ears like fans, legs like pillars, a back like a throne, all one gentle, grey elephant.
Perhaps then they would have laughed at their own quarrel and stood side by side, admiring the same beautiful thing.
The elephant, after all, had never been in pieces. Only their seeing had been.
May you carry a little candle of listening wherever you go, little one.
More from Sufi
- Source
- Story in the Sufi tradition
- Theme
- wisdom, calm, compassion
- Updated
Characters
- The townspeople
- — Each one sure of their own small piece.
- The elephant
- — Patient and gentle in the dark barn.
The moral
We each see only part of the truth, so we should listen to one another.
What to say to your baby
My little one, I am only beginning to know you, and every day I learn more. May you always listen and look with an open heart.
Ask them when they're older
Why did everyone think the elephant was something different?
Source: Jalaluddin Rumi, Masnavi, Book III, 'The Elephant in the Dark House'