Jataka · Story library
Young Mahosadha's Three Puzzles
Seven-year-old Mahosadha sits in his village hall. People bring him three quarrels: over a cow, a necklace and a chariot.
Moral of the story: Calm questions can find the truth.
In this story
- Characters
- Young Mahosadha, The villagers
- Source text
- Jataka tales
- Value
- Wisdom
- Read time
- 4 min read aloud
3 min read · pregnancy & ages 5–10 · also known as “Nanhe Mahosadh ki teen paheliyan Jataka”
Source: Jataka tales, Jataka No. 546 · Traditional retelling
Behind this story
These puzzles come from the Maha-ummagga Jataka, also called the Mahosadha Jataka, number 546 and one of the longest tales in the Pali collection, in which the Bodhisatta is a wise boy near Mithila. His early 'questions' are often compared to the judgements of Solomon, and the tale is a favourite in Sri Lanka, Myanmar and Thailand. What makes young Mahosadha special is that he never needs to accuse anyone: he asks gentle, practical questions, what a cow was fed, what perfume a necklace was kept in, and lets the truth show itself. The chariot puzzle, solved because 'men grow tired', adds a playful wonder. It is a cheerful wish for a calm, curious child who solves problems kindly.
Mahosadha shows that wisdom often looks like calm listening and a well-chosen question, not loud argument. Each quarrel ended with truth restored and the wrongdoer given a chance to make amends.
The true owner is a man, and men grow tired.
Long ago, in a little market village near the city of Mithila, there lived a boy named Mahosadha.
He was only seven years old, but he had built a hall at the crossroads with the help of his friends, a cool and shady place where travellers could rest and where anyone with a problem could come.
Mahosadha had a quiet way about him. He listened more than he spoke, and when he did speak, his questions were simple and kind.
One morning, a man came into the hall leading a cow, and another man came running after him.
"That is my cow!" shouted the second man. "He took her from my field!"
"No, she is mine!" said the first. "I bought her fair and square."
The villagers looked from one man to the other. Both looked angry. Both looked sure.
Mahosadha stroked the cow's soft nose. "Tell me," he said to each man in turn, "what did you feed her this morning?"
The man who had grabbed the cow said quickly, "Rice gruel and sesame cake and beans."
The other man said, "Only grass, the same as every morning."
Mahosadha asked for some leaves that gently settle a cow's stomach, mixed in water. The cow drank, then shook her head and brought up her breakfast, right there on the floor. Everyone leaned in to look. It was nothing but chewed green grass, without a single grain of rice or bean.
The villagers laughed and cheered. The cow went home with the man who had fed her grass, and the one who had taken her hung his head and promised never to do such a thing again.
A few days later, two women came into the hall, both holding on to one necklace made of bright coloured threads.
"I took it off to bathe in the pond," said the first woman, "and she asked to try it on, and then she walked off with it!"
"It has always been mine," said the second.
Mahosadha looked at the necklace and smiled. "Tell me," he said, "what perfume do you keep your necklace in?"
The second woman answered at once, "All kinds of sweet perfumes!"
The first woman said softly, "Only piyangu flowers. That is all I can afford."
Mahosadha lifted the necklace to his nose and breathed in. It smelled of piyangu flowers and nothing else.
So the necklace went home with its true owner, and the other woman, blushing, admitted the truth and asked to be forgiven.
Then one hot afternoon, a man came in, red-faced and puffing. "I stopped my chariot by the road," he panted, "and stepped down for just a moment. This shining stranger climbed in and now says it is his!"
The stranger stood calmly, cool and untroubled, with not a drop of sweat on him.
Mahosadha thought for a moment. Then he said, "Let the chariot drive off, and both of you run behind it and catch hold of it. Whoever holds on is the owner."
The chariot rolled away. The owner ran and ran, panting, his feet raising dust, until he had to let go and sit by the road. But the stranger ran easily beside it, as light as a breeze, his skin never even damp.
Mahosadha turned to the crowd. "Do you see? The true owner is a man, and men grow tired. The one who never tires and never sweats cannot be a man at all."
The shining stranger laughed with delight. He was Sakka, the king of the gods, who had come down only to see the wisdom of the boy. "You have judged well, little one," he said, and he gave back the chariot and blessed the hall before vanishing into the sky.
Soon the whole kingdom spoke about the boy who settled quarrels without shouting, only by asking the right gentle question.
Sleep now, little one. May you grow up asking kind and clever questions, and may the truth always find its way home.
More from Jataka tales
- Source
- Traditional retelling
- Theme
- wisdom, truthfulness, calm
- Updated
Characters
- Young Mahosadha
- — A wise boy who asks calm questions.
- The villagers
- — Who bring their quarrels to him.
The moral
Calm questions can find the truth.
What to say to your baby
Little one, may you think calmly, ask good questions and always seek the truth.
Ask them when they're older
How did Mahosadha solve the quarrels?
Source: Maha-ummagga (Mahosadha) Jataka, Jataka No. 546 (Cowell, The Jataka, Vol. VI)