Women of India · Day 167 · Week 24
Gargi and the Great Question
At King Janaka's gathering of wise teachers, Gargi rises to question the sage Yajnavalkya. Step by step she asks what everything is woven on.
Moral of the story: A question is a lamp, not a fight.
In this story
- Characters
- Gargi, Yajnavalkya, King Janaka
- Source text
- Upanishads
- Value
- Wisdom
- Read time
- 5 min read aloud
Day 167 at a glance
- Week
- Week 24 · day 6 of 7
- Trimester
- Trimester 2
- Baby this week
- The lungs develop branches and cells that produce surfactant. Baby has regular sleep-wake cycles. Week 24 baby development
- Today's story
- Gargi and the Great Question
- Mantra
- Gayatri Mantra
- Garbh samvad
- “When I talk, do you move? I think you're answering me.” Talk to your baby this week
Tradition holds, in the Brihadaranyaka Upanishad, that Gargi Vachaknavi questioned the sage Yajnavalkya with courage and humility, and she is honoured as one of India's great women scholars. Research on maternal calm suggests that curiosity and gentle wonder may help a mother feel engaged and uplifted.
"A question is not a fight. It is a lamp."
Lamps glowed under painted pillars in the court of King Janaka of Videha. His palace was not famous for its gold. It was famous for its questions.
Every year King Janaka invited the wisest teachers in the land. They sat on mats of soft grass while incense curled up towards the ceiling. And they talked about the biggest things a mind can hold. What is the world made of? What holds the stars in place? What is the self that looks out through our eyes?
One year the king made a special offer. He had gold coins tied to the horns of a thousand cows.
"These are for the wisest teacher here," he said. "Let the wisest one lead them home."
The great sage Yajnavalkya stood up calmly and asked his student to lead the cows away. The court murmured. Was he really the wisest? Then the questions began.
One learned man after another asked him difficult things. One by one, he answered. The lamps burned lower.
Then a woman rose from her mat. Her name was Gargi Vachaknavi.
Gargi had studied since she was a girl. She loved the Vedas. She loved the night sky. Most of all, she loved asking why. Her mother used to say, "Gargi, your questions are like a river. They never stop flowing."
Now she stood in front of the whole court. Some people looked surprised. A woman, questioning the great sage? But Gargi did not shrink. Her voice was clear and steady.
"Yajnavalkya," she said, "everything we see is woven on water, like cloth on a loom. So what is water woven on?"
The sage smiled. He liked a good question. "On air, Gargi."
"And what is air woven on?"
"On the sky, the open space."
Gargi nodded and went on. The sky, then the worlds of light, then the sun and moon, then the stars. Each answer opened a new door, and each time she stepped gently through it.
The court went very quiet.
At last Yajnavalkya raised his hand kindly. "Gargi, do not ask beyond asking. Some questions must rest for a while."
Gargi paused. She did not feel ashamed. She felt like a traveller who has walked a long way and sees great mountains ahead. She sat down and breathed.
Then she stood again.
"I have two more questions," she told the court. "They are like two arrows in the hands of a skilled archer. If he can answer them, no one here will beat him in talk of the highest truth."
The king leaned forward.
"What is above the sky and below the earth?" Gargi asked. "What is between them? What is past, present and future? On what is all of this woven?"
Yajnavalkya closed his eyes. When he spoke, his voice was soft. He spoke of the Akshara, the Imperishable, the quiet something behind everything. It cannot be seen, he said, yet it sees. It cannot be heard, yet it hears. By its order, the sun and moon keep their paths, and rivers find their way to the sea.
Gargi listened with her whole heart. When he finished, she turned to the court.
"Honour him," she said simply. "He knows."
There was no anger in her voice and no wish to win. She had asked because she wanted to understand, and now she understood a little more.
That evening Gargi walked out into the courtyard under the stars. The stone was cool and still. A young girl, the daughter of a palace cook, came and stood beside her.
"Weren't you afraid?" the girl asked. "All those men were watching."
Gargi laughed. "A little," she said. "But a question is not a fight. It is a lamp. When you carry a lamp, you think about the light, not the dark."
The girl looked up at the sky. "Then may I ask you a question?"
"Always," said Gargi.
"Where do the stars go in the daytime?"
Gargi sat down on the warm stone step. "Ah," she said. "Now that is a beautiful question. Let us wonder about it together."
So they sat there, a learned woman and a curious child, pointing out stars one by one, until the cook came looking for her daughter with a lamp in her hand.
Little one, ask all your questions; someone will always sit down on the step beside you.
More from Upanishads
4 min read · pregnancy & ages 3–8 · also known as “Gargi aur Yajnavalkya ki kahani”
Source: Upanishads · Traditional retelling
Behind this story
Gargi Vachaknavi's questions to the sage Yajnavalkya come from the Brihadaranyaka Upanishad, set at King Janaka's assembly in Videha, where a thousand cows with gold on their horns await the wisest teacher. She is one of the best-remembered women thinkers of the Vedic age, often named whenever India's tradition of women scholars is discussed. What makes her moment distinctive is its shape: a chain of 'woven on what?' questions climbing from water to air to sky, a pause when told not to ask too far, and then two final questions 'like arrows'. She ends by honouring the sage rather than defeating him. A fine story for pregnancy, it treats curiosity as a lamp to share.
- Theme
- wisdom, courage, wonder
- For pregnancy week
- This story is for week 24 of pregnancy
- Updated
Characters
- Gargi
- — A curious thinker whose questions are lamps.
- Yajnavalkya
- — The calm sage who answers kindly.
- King Janaka
- — The king who loves wisdom.
The moral
A question is a lamp, not a fight.
What to say to your baby
Little one, ask all your questions. I will always sit beside you and wonder with you.
Ask them when they're older
Where do you think the stars go in the daytime?
Source: Brihadaranyaka Upanishad (Gargi's questions to Yajnavalkya at Janaka's court)