Garbh Katha
Start free

Sufi · Story library

Mulla Nasruddin: Which Is More Useful, the Sun or the Moon?

At the teahouse, villagers argue whether the sun or the moon is more useful. Mulla Nasruddin says the moon, because it shines at night when we need light.

Moral of the story: Laughter reminds us to be thankful for every gift.

In this story

Characters
Mulla Nasruddin, The farmer and the caravan driver
Source text
Nasreddin Hodja folklore, retold in Idries Shah's Nasrudin books
Value
Wonder
Read time
4 min read aloud
Also spelled
Mulla Nasruddin / Nasruddin / Nasreddin / Mulla / Hodja / Nasreddin Hodja

3 min read · pregnancy & ages 3–8 · also known as “Mulla Nasruddin – chand ya suraj”

Source: Story in the Sufi tradition

Behind this story

Teahouses across Turkey, Iran and Central Asia have echoed with Nasreddin Hodja's jokes for centuries, and this riddle of the sun and the moon is one of the best loved, retold in Idries Shah's Nasrudin books. The farmer argues for the sun, the caravan driver for the moon, and the Mulla's topsy-turvy logic, that the moon is more useful because it shines when we need light, sets the whole room laughing. What makes this telling sweet is its afterglow: walking home under the stars, each man feels lucky to have both. Its gentle humour and closing image of the moon keeping watch make it a cosy bedtime read for a mother-to-be.

Nasruddin's upside-down logic invites laughter and a second look at the world. Behind the joke is gratitude for both the busy light of day and the soft light of night.

Because the moon shines at night, when it is dark and we really need the light.

At the edge of the village square there was a little teahouse with low wooden benches, a big brass samovar, and a vine that made a green roof overhead. In late summer bunches of purple grapes hung down, so close you could almost reach them from your seat.

Every evening, when the day's work was done, the men of the village gathered there. They sipped sweet tea from small glasses and cracked walnuts and talked about everything under the sky.

Mulla Nasruddin was always there, in his favourite corner, with his round turban and his twinkling eyes. Wherever he sat, laughter was never far away.

One evening the talk turned to the sky itself. The sun was setting, painting the rooftops orange and pink, and a pale moon was just rising over the hills.

"Tell me, friends," said the potter, wiping clay from his hands, "which is more useful to us, the sun or the moon?"

"The sun, of course!" said the farmer. "It ripens my wheat and my melons. Without it nothing would grow, not a single apricot or grain of rice."

"The sun dries the clothes on the line," added the weaver. "It dries my dyed wool in bright, beautiful colours."

"But the moon guides travellers at night," said the caravan driver softly. "I have followed its silver path across the desert many times."

The men argued back and forth, waving their tea glasses. The walnuts went crack, crack, crack. The samovar bubbled and sang, and the tea boy hurried about refilling glasses.

At last everyone turned to the corner. "Mulla," they said, "you are the wise one. You settle it. Which is more useful, the sun or the moon?"

Nasruddin set down his glass. He stroked his beard. He looked up through the vines at the rising moon, and then at the last orange glow of the sun.

The teahouse went quiet. Even the samovar seemed to bubble more softly, waiting.

"The moon," said Nasruddin, "is far more useful than the sun."

"The moon?" said the farmer, astonished. "But why, Mulla? Please explain!"

Nasruddin spread his hands, as if it was the most obvious thing in the world.

"Because the moon shines at night, when it is dark and we really need the light," he said. "But the sun shines in the daytime, when it is already light anyway!"

For a moment nobody said a word. Then the potter snorted into his tea. The weaver clutched his belly. The caravan driver laughed until his eyes were wet.

The whole teahouse rang with laughter, so loud that the sleepy pigeons on the roof fluttered up and settled down again.

"Oh, Mulla!" gasped the farmer. "But it is the sun that makes the day light!"

Nasruddin only smiled and sipped his tea, his eyes twinkling. Had he made a mistake? Or had he made them all laugh on purpose? Nobody could ever quite tell.

As the stars came out one by one, the men walked home along the moonlit lanes. They were still chuckling, and they kept looking up at the sky.

The farmer looked at the moon and thought of his melons sleeping in the field. The weaver thought of tomorrow's sunshine on his colourful wool.

And each of them thought, in his own quiet way, how lucky we are to have both: a warm sun for working and growing, and a gentle moon for resting and dreaming.

Nasruddin walked home last of all, humming, with the moonlight silver on his turban. At his door he paused and bowed to the moon, just a little.

"Thank you for the light," he whispered. "And tomorrow, I will thank the sun too."

So close your eyes now, little one. The moon is keeping watch, and the sun will come back in the morning to say hello.

Read the next story →Mulla Nasruddin and the Lost Key

More from Mulla Nasruddin

Source
Story in the Sufi tradition
Theme
wonder, wisdom, calm
Updated

Characters

Mulla Nasruddin
— A funny judge with a topsy-turvy answer.
The farmer and the caravan driver
— Friends who each love a different light.

The moral

Laughter reminds us to be thankful for every gift.

What to say to your baby

Close your eyes, little one. The moon is keeping watch, and the sun will come back in the morning.

Ask them when they're older

Which did the Mulla say is more useful, and why?

Source: Nasreddin Hodja folklore, retold in Idries Shah's Nasrudin books

हिन्दी में पढ़ें

Reflect with your baby

What gives you light on the darker, quieter evenings of this pregnancy?

Affirmation: I welcome both my busy days and my restful nights with gratitude.

Blessing: May a warm sun light your days and a gentle moon watch over your nights.

To carry this story's wonder into your day, try a few minutes of pregnancy meditation and breathing, and read the pregnancy diet chart.

Related stories

  • Nasruddin Saves the Moon

    Similar story

    This much-loved Nasruddin tale brings gentle laughter and a big, caring heart. It also hints at a quiet truth: a reflection is not the real thing, and the real light is safe and whole above us.

Frequently asked questions

What does the story of Mulla Nasruddin: Which Is More Useful, the Sun or the Moon? teach?

Nasruddin's upside-down logic invites laughter and a second look at the world. Behind the joke is gratitude for both the busy light of day and the soft light of night.

Where does the story of Mulla Nasruddin: Which Is More Useful, the Sun or the Moon? come from?

A well-known Nasreddin Hodja joke from Turkish and Persian folklore, retold in Idries Shah's Nasrudin books. The teahouse setting and the Mulla's goodnight to the moon are added village detail; the answer itself is traditional.

More stories like this

Pair it with a mantra: Om (ॐ) — meaning and how to chant

Share with someone expecting